Protecting Critical Systems in Unbounded Networks

Contact:http://www.packetnexus.com

Protecting Critical Systems in Unbounded Networks
Robert J. Ellison, David A. Fisher, 
Richard C. Linger, Howard F. Lipson, 
Thomas A. Longstaff, Nancy R. Mead
 

Society is growing increasingly dependent on large-scale, highly
distributed systems that operate in unbounded network environments.
Unbounded networks, such as the Internet, have no central administrative
control and no unified security policy. Furthermore, the number and
nature of the nodes connected to such networks cannot be fully known.
Despite the best efforts of security practitioners, no amount of
hardening can assure that a system that is connected to an unbounded
network will be invulnerable to attack. The discipline of survivability
can help ensure that such systems can deliver essential services and
maintain essential properties such as integrity, confidentiality, and
performance, despite the presence of intrusions.

 

The New Network Paradigm:
Organizational Integration

From their modest beginnings some 20 years ago, computer networks have
become a critical element of modern society. These networks not only
have global reach; they also affect virtually every aspect of human
endeavor. Networked systems are principal enabling agents in business,
industry, government, and defense. Major economic sectors, including
defense, energy, transportation, telecommunications, manufacturing,
financial services, health care, and education, all depend on a vast
array of networks operating on local, national, and global scales. This
pervasive societal dependence on networks magnifies the consequences of
intrusions, accidents, and failures, and amplifies the critical
importance of ensuring network survivability. 

A new network paradigm is emerging. Networks are being used to achieve
radical new levels of organizational integration. This integration
obliterates traditional organizational boundaries and integrates local
operations into components of comprehensive, network-based business
processes. For example, commercial organizations are integrating
operations with business units, suppliers, and customers through
large-scale networks that enhance communication and services. These
networks combine previously fragmented operations into coherent
processes open to many organizational participants. This new paradigm
represents a shift from bounded networks with central control to
unbounded networks.

Unbounded networks are characterized by distributed administrative
control without central authority, limited visibility beyond the
boundaries of local administration, and a lack of complete information
about the entire network. At the same time, organizations' dependence on
networks is increasing, and the risks and consequences of intrusions and
compromises are amplified.

The Internet is an example of an unbounded environment with many
client-server network applications. A public Web server and its clients
may exist within many different administrative domains on the Internet.
Many business-to-business Web-based e-commerce applications depend on
conventions within a specific industry segment for interoperability.
Within the Internet, there is little distinction between insiders and
outsiders. Everyone who chooses to connect to the Internet is an
insider, whether or not they are known to a particular subsystem. This
characteristic is the result of the desire, and modern necessity, for
connectivity. A company cannot survive in a highly competitive industry
without easy and rapid access to its customers, suppliers, and partners.

More and more, a company's partners on one pr